Skip to Main Content

Comp II -Sebourn: Evaluating Sources

The guide is for students in Ms. Sebourn's Comp II class who are working on an annotated bilbiography.

Primary Documents

What is a primary document? 

  • Examples of primary documents/sources include: original documents (like the actual United States Constitution), research articles, diaries, interviews, personal accounts of events, eye-witness experiences and live-action news. (created by Indiana University East-Campus Library)
  • The Primary Source organization provides a thoughtful explanation of the concept of primary sources and documents.
  • Use the Primary Sources Tutorial from U of California: Irvine.

Refereed/Peer-reviewed?--from Indiana University East

Experts in a field (singly or several people) review an author's work by its written description for methods, plausibility, completeness, ethics, etc. to "weed-out" poorly documented/conceived research, implausible research, poorly constructed research, dishonest research,etc. The hard sciences may also apply a more stringent idea of peer-reviewed by including the idea of blind peer-review. This kind of peer review excludes author and other personal information from the review process. In this case the "editor" as a peer-reviewer is removed from the process.

--created by Indiana University East--Campus Library

Advanced Writing: Evaluating Sources

Research Minutes: How to Identify Scholarly Journal Articles

Peer Review

From libncsu (NCSU Libraries),, May 1, 2014